Skip to content
Log in
← Glossary

coaching conversation

Also called: coaching conversations, coaching a report, manager as coach

A conversation in which the lead mostly asks rather than tells, helping a person clarify the goal, look at the current situation, find their own options and commit to a next step. It suits people who have the skills but are stuck; someone who lacks the skill needs teaching first.

A coaching conversation is one where the lead mostly asks rather than tells, so that the person thinks through their own goal and chooses their own next step. A simple path has four stops: the goal (theirs, concrete, with a date), today's reality (facts and what they have already tried, not their potential), the options (asking "What else?" at least twice, because the third idea is often the useful one), and one next step the person owns, with a date and a way to report back.

It fits when the person has the skill and the knowledge and the goal is theirs: growing into a bigger role, solving a problem they are stuck on, improving something they already do well. Studies of workplace coaching generally find positive effects on goal attainment and skills, though the size varies a lot. It is the wrong tool when the cause is something else. Unclear expectations need setting, not questions. A skill gap needs teaching and a worked example first. A performance problem that keeps hurting customers needs direct feedback on the behavior. And stress, health or a personal crisis needs listening and a pointer to professional help: a lead is not a therapist.

Coaching doesn't mean hiding your view. Share your idea after theirs, as one option among several. Let the person write the step in their own words, because a step you write for them quietly becomes your plan. On a video call, silence feels longer than it is: wait a few seconds before you fill a pause with advice. Follow up at the next one-to-one, and if the step didn't happen, ask what got in the way, without blame.

Example

August 2027. At her one-to-one Olha, Klasna's longest-serving support coordinator, says she wants to be ready to lead a team one day. The lead's instinct is to hand her a list of tasks. Instead:

Stop
Question
What Olha says
Goal
"What would 'ready to lead' look like for you by December?"
Plan the September restart on her own: rota, onboarding, hand-up rules
Reality
"What have you planned on your own, and what got in the way?"
The hard-ticket rotation in February; when a newcomer is stuck, she takes the ticket herself
Options
"When you take the ticket, what does the newcomer learn? What could you try? What else?"
Pair instead of taking over; write up the five hardest ticket types; a practice hour before the September hires start
Next step
"What will you do first, and by when?"
By the 20th, the five hardest ticket types written up, and two weeks of pairing; she brings both to the next one-to-one

The lead adds one idea only after hers: present the rota to Iryna herself.

Choosing the tool is part of the job. Maryna wants to explain the refund policy better to upset parents, and her quality is the team's best (2.00% reopened, 94.93% satisfied, January–July): she can find her own answer, so coaching fits. Taras on refund requests is a different case: in the six months to February he solved 60 and handed up 70 (a solo rate of 46.15%), and 25.00% of those he solved were reopened. That is a skill gap, so teaching and a worked example come first.

Common mistakes

  • Asking leading questions. "Don't you think you should…?" is advice in disguise; ask open questions.
  • Coaching a skill gap. Someone who has never done the task needs teaching first.
  • Coaching a performance problem for weeks. A pattern that hurts customers needs direct feedback on behavior.
  • Writing the next step for them. Their step, their words, their date.
  • Never following up. Ask about the step at the next one-to-one, and ask what got in the way without blame.

Learn it in the course